by Mark Silva, updated with full results
Mitt Romney, former governor of Massachusetts and a late-comer to the anti-abortion cause, claimed a narrow victory today in a straw poll of Christian conservative voters assembled in Washington and collecting votes from members online.
Mike Huckabee, former governor of Arkansas and a former Baptist pastor, placed a close second in this informal poll – with Romney claiming 1,595 votes and Huckabee 1,565. Among votes cast on-site, however, Huckabee, clear favorite in a hall full of conservative voters, claimed more than half of the total ballots.
The results of this conference of Christian conservatives serve as a stark rebuke to the Republican Party’s front-running candidate for president in national polling, Rudy Giuliani, the former mayor of New York. Giuliani, alone among his party’s candidates, supports abortion rights for women – which many among the Christian right consider a deal-breaker for him.
Giuliani did not place among the top-four finishers in the straw poll here -- indeed, Giuliani finished eighth of nine candidates, with just 107 votes out of 5,776 cast.
.
With evangelical Protestants accounting for nearly one in four of all Republican voters, the message coming from the two-day “Values Voter Summit’’ sponsored by the Family Research Council is clear: Many of the party’s “social conservatives’’ are more concerned about aligning with a candidate who advances their causes of abolishing abortion and enshrining marriage as a union of man and woman in the Constitution than in supporting a candidate such as Giuliani who may prove more electable.
Yet the results of the straw-poll staged after two days of speeches from all the party’s presidential candidates may say less about the actual political prospects for either Romney or Huckabee in a crowded Republican contest.
"I think, clearly, there is a consensus building around one, two or maybe three candidates,'' said Tony Perkins, Family Research Council president, hoping that this straw poll will help social conservatives start to rally around one candidate for president.
While 1,537 people inside the ballroom of the Washington Hilton cast ballots, so did many more people who were able to join the Family Research Council online and then cast their own votes. The Romney campaign had waged a concerted effort to enlist online votes from supporters of the former Massachusetts governor, who was not entirely warmly received in the hall here – indeed the announcement of the results in the hall today were received with silence, another clear sign that Huckabee was the winner of the hall.
That was born out in the numbers: While 1,537 people here voted, some of them voted online and 952 cast their votes on-site. In the on-site vote, Huckabee collected 488 -- more than half, and far and away more than any other candidate. Romney collected just 99 on-site.
With 5,776 ballots overall cast in this straw poll, Rep. Ron Paul of Texas placed third, with 865 votes, and former Tennessee Sen. Fred Thompson placed fourth, with 564 ballots. Paul's vote, too, is a sign of the following that he has developed on the Internet.
The overall totals:
Romney: 1,595
Huckabee: 1,565
Paul: 865
Thompson: 564
Sam Brownback, who has quit the race: 297
Duncan Hunter: 140
Tom Tancredo: 133
Giuliani: 107
John McCain: 81