The Swamp
-
Posted November 19, 2007 9:51 AM
The Swamp

by Josh Drobnyk

Few Pennsylvanians may have heard of GOP presidential candidate Mike Huckabee. Pat Toomey wants to keep it that way.

Toomey, the former Lehigh Valley congressman who now heads the anti-tax group Club for Growth, has been on a relentless campaign to undermine the former Arkansas governor's bid for the White House, which has gathered steam after a strong performance in the Iowa straw poll in August.

The Club for Growth has unleashed almost daily diatribes against Huckabee in recent weeks, criticizing him for hiking taxes during his tenure in the Arkansas state house, including a boost in the gas tax to help fix the state's roads. Huckabee counters that his record has been distorted and the gas tax increase was widely popular with the state's voters.

''Mike Huckabee is a unique candidate in this Republican field in that he is clearly a committed social conservative, but he is economically very liberal,'' Toomey said in an interview. ''And he is the only economic liberal in the field.''

Huckabee has seen his presidential stock rise since he placed second to Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney in the influential straw poll. And while three other GOP presidential contenders -- former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani, former Tennessee Sen. Fred Thompson and Arizona Sen. John McCain -- didn't participate in the poll, the showing has led to a significant boost in Huckabee's popularity.

Recent polls in Iowa, which is set to kick off the primary calendar with a caucus on Jan. 3, show Huckabee trailing only Romney in the state. Nationally, he has more work to do; he polls fifth in most nationwide surveys.

But even in Pennsylvania, a state whose primary is scheduled for late April and that has received scant attention from the candidates, Huckabee is gaining momentum. He received 6 percent in a November Quinnipiac University poll, up from 2 percent in October.

''He has proven to be a very credible candidate,'' said Harrisburg-based GOP consultant Charlie Gerow, who is not affiliated with any of the White House hopefuls.

A former Baptist preacher, Huckabee has strong support from the religious base of the Republican Party in a race that has social conservatives less than ecstatic about the GOP field. He opposes abortion rights and federal funding for stem cell research. He supports a constitutional ban on gay marriage.

His name has often been mentioned as a possible vice presidential choice should he lose the nomination.

And that's precisely what worries Toomey, who has sought to steer the GOP toward a more fiscally conservative mantle.

The Club for Growth, which Toomey joined soon after leaving Congress in 2005, has not shied away from going after fellow Republicans. It was Toomey, after all, who was aided by the group in his unsuccessful Republican primary race against Sen. Arlen Specter in 2004.

''Republicans have to lead with a consistent message of free markets and fiscal conservatism and Mike Huckabee would completely ruin an effort to try to re-establish that brand,'' Toomey said.

Huckabee's office didn't return a call for comment. The former governor has defended his fiscal record by pointing to an array of tax cuts he signed into law during his tenure, from 1996 to this year. On the gas and diesel tax boost, which he signed into law in 1999, Huckabee has repeatedly argued the measure was a ballot initiative that won widespread support.

''Did we raise taxes on fuel? Yes. But 80 percent of the people voted on it because it was on the ballot,'' he said earlier this year on NBC's ''Meet the Press.'' ''So it wasn't that I raised it. I joined with 80 percent of the people in my state to improve what was the worst road system in the country.''

That argument has infuriated the Club for Growth, prompting continuous jabs in recent days from the group that Huckabee was ''fibbing'' about his record. The group noted in a video it posted on YouTube.com that Huckabee signed the fuel tax hike two months before a $547 million bond issue for road improvement was approved in a referendum.

Toomey's tough rhetoric hasn't been equally shared among other prominent fiscal conservatives. Huckabee has signed the Americans for Tax Reform's pledge to fight future tax increases, a factor welcomed by the organization's president, Grover Norquist.

''He has a troublesome history in supporting tax increases as governor, as did Ronald Reagan,'' Norquist told the National Review magazine for a September profile. ''But in running for president, he has made a written commitment that he would oppose tax increases.''

Huckabee isn't the only GOP candidate to draw Toomey's ire. Earlier this year, Toomey wrote a scathing review of McCain's fiscal bona fides, prompting a short-lived spat between the pair.

''We think part of our role is to make clear what these guys stand for,'' Toomey said. He said he's unsure if he'll endorse a candidate before the primary is over, although he has written generally positive reviews of Giuliani, Thompson and Romney.

Toomey is considered an influential voice among conservatives and his assault on Huckabee's tax record has not gone unnoticed. After he penned a critique in National Review in late October, headlined ''Dump the Huck,'' CNN's Wolf Blitzer asked Huckabee about the diatribe.

''As long as you're getting kicked in the rear, you're still out front,'' Huckabee said. ''I'm kind of enjoying…the fact that all of these attacks are coming. It proves…that I'm flying.''

Gerow agreed. But the key for Huckabee, he noted, is surviving the onslaught.

''When you start getting this kind of incoming fire you know that you are a real player,'' Gerow said. ''The question is whether Huckabee is able to deflect this criticism.''

Digg Delicious Facebook Fark Google Newsvine Reddit Yahoo

Comments

Anyone interested in what Huckabee is really like face to face should try this funny (but it actually happened) column:
http://goupstate.us/index.php/lanefiller/2007/11/02/title_14


What is the Club for Growth's alternative plan to fix roads and highways in Arkansas? Allow corporations to take them over and charge residents and travelers fees to cross bridges and traverse the state? Give me a break. Huckabee fixed a problem and he rallied support to do it. That's what leaders do. Take note George W.


For the truth about Gay Marriage check out our trailer. Produced to educate & defuse the controversy it has a way of opening closed minds & creates an interesting spin on the issue: www.OUTTAKEonline.com


Why does the Club for Growth not point out that, while the Governor's Mansion in Arkansas was being renovated, Huckabee and his Wife actually moved into a MOBILE HOME parked on the premises to save Arkansans money?

He did support some tax increases for us, but did so for excellent reasons. Prior to his highway program, driving down I30 or I40 in Arkansas was like driving down a gravel road (this was after years of Clinton Rule).

When he left, the treasury had a billion dollar surplus (a lot for a small state).

And contrary to the vendetta carried by by Max Brantley (author of the Salon article) the man has more integrity than any politician I've seen in 50 years.

He's a fine man, and would make a fine president.


Don't you just love Republican on Republican hate??

Keep it up guys - makes the Dems run to the White House that much easier.


Huckabee is well suited to serve in Arkansas. Nothing more. He is a joke as a presidential candidate. The GOP is grasping at staws. No pun intended.


Club for Growth has tunnel vision. It doesn't matter if the money was needed to improve infrastructure or education. It doesn't matter. It doesn't matter that Gov. Huckabee CUT taxes 94 times. It doesn't matter. Club for Growth's opinion doesn't matter to me.

Mike Huckabee's proven himself a leader. Tried and true. Fiscal and Social Conservative. Independent Conservative, that is. I like Mike.


Why does anyone reprint these same, tired smear articles from Club For Growth? CFG and Toomey are pushing the agenda of a wealthy Arkansas businessman named Jackson Stephens. Everyone in Arkansas knows the Stephens family has been trying to ruin Mike Huckabee because Mr. Huckabee wouldn't be swayed by their money to push certain legislation in 2002. Stephens has been one of the biggest financial contributors to CFG over the last several years...hence the personal vendetta against Huckabee. Why else would CFG go after MH months ago when he was at about 2-3% in national polls???


Mike Huckabee has all the attributes to be
President of the United States of America.
For anyone that reads this take sometime
out and go to his website,or listen to him
speak.He far surpasses all the competition
on either side of the aisle.


I think Toomey and the Club For Growth is just basking in this political limelight primarliy for selfish publicity sake only - and the national media is obliging them. Their motives are not for the public's sake, for their own, it's abundantly obvious.


I won't be voting for Huckabee, but "Club for Growth" is really a strange name for a group that objects to balanced budgets, and government investment in infrastructure and education. How about "Club for Deficit Spending" or "Club for Collapsing Highways" or "Club for an Uneducated Workforce".


Who are the largest donors of the CFG? How does the CFG feel about Mike's brilliant adoption of the FairTax? How do they feel about MH being the only 1st-tier FairTax supporter? Get these questions answered before you post another wasteful Club for Growth report.


Mikes the man for the job!


Huckabee is gathering momentum fast because he word is spreading through the religious right. It is word of mouth...pastor to pastor...Christian to Christian. Old fashion gossip at work :)


I could care less what Club for Greed..err Growth has to say.


Either Pat Toomey is way underinformed about Huckabee and the distinctions of state vs. federal government, or his campaign against Huckabee is a disingenuous mercenary payoff: I suspect th latter, which is what serious inquiry suggests. But, if he wants to admith that he doesn't know any better, OK. But either way, I consider his counsel invalid.


Apparently, the Club for Growth is against Huckabee's FairTax plan - which, if enacted, would represent the largest restoration of power to working Americans in over 90 years. Pat Toomey must be oblivious to Economist Laurence Kotlikoff's belief that, unless the FairTax is passed, we can look forward to an economic meltdown.


Fiscally liberal? Has Pat Toomey ever sat down and read The FairTax Act (HR 25, S 1025 for himself? I mean REALLY read it, not the cliff notes! This is the single best chance the American people have to taking back the power from the political want to be's. It is a far, far better plan than the 62,000 page tax code that is in place now! the health and wealth of our country starts with Tax Reform, you better believe that! Money is the root of all evil.


I'm not a big fan of the neocon Club for Growth, but they are right about Huckabee. Even those with much better conservative credentials, such as Phyllis Schafly, have exposed Huckabee as a tax-and-spend big-government guy.


Post a comment

(Anonymous comments will not be posted. Comments aren't posted immediately. They're screened for relevance to the topic, obscenity, spam and over-the-top personal attacks. We can't always get them up as soon as we'd like so please be patient. Thanks for visiting The Swamp.)

Please enter the letter "y" in the field below:

Election 2008
Tag Cloud
[What is this?]