Vietnamese rights activists press Congress to act: The Swamp
The Swamp
Posted March 12, 2008 2:40 PM
The Swamp

by Mark Silva

A decade after the United States restored relations with Vietnam, lawmakers are being asked to confront the continuing denial of democratic rights in the Socialist Republic of Vietnam.

Do Hoang Diem, chairman of Viet Tan (the Vietnam Reform Pary) appeared before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee’s subcommittee on East Asian and Pacific Affairs in a hearing today. He was joined by the wife of an imprisoned democratic activist in Vietnam, in jail for nearly four months.

““It is clear that what is happening in Vietnam is very unusual and significant,’’ he told the committee. “After more than 50 years in power, for the first time, the Vietnamese Communist Party is facing numerous and unprecedented challenges to its rule. The desire for real changes in Vietnam is stronger now than ever before. In response, the regime is using terror tactics to silence opposition, and severely violate human rights of not just political dissidents but also bloggers, farmers, workers, students or whoever dares to question the regime’s authority.’’

Dr. Nguyen Quoc Quan was arrested along with five other democracy activists on Nov. 17, the party says, though the Vietnamese government did not acknowledge the arrest for 10 days. In December, after international protest, Vietnam released the other two democracy activists, one American, Leo Truong, and one French.

Since then, the party says, the U.S. Consulate in Saigon has been allowed to visit Dr. Quan once a month – but no family visits have been allowed.

His wife applied for visa to go to Vietnam to visit her husband in January. She was granted the visa but no permission to visit him. On Feb. 19, the Vietnamese Consulate revoked Mrs. Nguyen's visa to Vietnam, one week before her scheduled trip.

On March 17, Quan will have been arrested for four months. “According to Vietnamese law, the authorities can keep Mr. Quan up to 4 months with out charges,’’ the party says. “This means the Vietnamese government has to make a decision soon what they want to do with Dr. Quan.’’

In Vietnam today, the Viet Tan party chairman said in prepared testimony for the committee, “There are two important developments: a surge in social discontent and an emboldened challenge to one-party rule.

““First, due to pervasive corruption, social discontent has risen to an unprecedented level,’’ he said. “ This is shown by widespread protests by farmers and labor unrest. For almost two years, farmers have staged numerous protests to demand fair compensation for land lost to corrupt officials.

“The most significant event was the 27 days protest in Saigon last summer by thousands of people before the police forcibly removed them,’’ he told the committee. “Workers also have walked out by the thousands in hundreds of strikes. More recently, even the mostly quite Catholic community joined in when thousands of followers protested from December 2007 into January of this year demanding the return of confiscated church properties in Hanoi.

“Meanwhile, the government continues to arbitrarily arrest those suspected of leading the protests and harassing others who participated,’’ he said. “However, so far this has failed to prevent new protests from taking place. ‘’

Likiening the democracy movement in Vietnam today to Czechoslovakia’s during the 1970s and Poland’s in the 1980s, he said, “For the first time, the movement no longer consists of individuals but organized groups with increasing popular support. Since 2006, dozens of political parties and grassroots associations have sprung up to challenge one-party rule. The government retaliated in February 2007 when they unleashed the worst crack down in the last 20 years.

“Scores of democracy leaders have been imprisoned; others put under house arrest or subjected to constant harassment by the police,’’ he said. “Although battered by the crack down, these groups are still hanging on and building coalitions from both overseas and inside Vietnam.

On Nov. 17, three members of his party, Viet Tan, were arrested for attempting to publicize non-violent principles and methods.

“Dr. Nguyen Quoc Quan of California is still in prison today. Just last week, his wife’s visa to Vietnam was retracted despite her plea to visit her husband. Mrs. Nguyen Quoc Quan is at the hearing today as a vivid reminder that the Vietnamese people are still living under a brutal and dictatorial regime.

“It is clear that what is happening in Vietnam is very unusual and significant. After more than 50 years in power, for the first time, the Vietnamese Communist Party is facing numerous and unprecedented challenges to its rule. The desire for real changes in Vietnam is stronger now than ever before. In response, the regime is using terror tactics to silence opposition, and severely violate human rights of not just political dissidents but also bloggers, farmers, workers, students or whoever dares to question the regime’s authority.

“The democracy movement in Vietnam is facing a huge challenge: that is to survive the crackdown at all costs. And by overcoming the challenge, a tremendous opportunity also exists. If the movement can survive the next year or two, it will prove to the Vietnamese people that: 1) There is a viable alternative that can withstand the persecution and continues to challenge the regime, and 2) Fear can be overcome for the ruling dictatorship is not as invincible as it claims. And that will lead to a tipping point to accelerate real democratic changes.

“For the United States, an excellent opportunity also exists because: 1) A democratic Vietnam will be a much more reliable partner in the long run on both economic and security fronts, especially in dealing with China, and 2) A victory for democracy in Vietnam will have a tremendous impact on political openness and respect for human rights throughout the region.


“The choice for American policy is not whether to isolate or engage Vietnam, but how to pursue the bilateral relationship in the most constructive way'' he said "To deepen America’s relationship with the Vietnamese people, I would like to offer three recommendations:

"1) Send the Vietnam Human Rights Act to President Bush for his signature. Last September, the House of Representatives overwhelmingly passed the Vietnam Human Rights Act (H.R. 3096). This result was warmly welcomed by the Vietnamese American community and democracy activists inside Vietnam. In a letter thanking the House, the Vietnam-based Alliance for Democracy and Human Rights stated:

“The fraternal and economic relationship between Vietnam and the United States is only sustainable and benefiting the peoples of the two countries when Vietnam is truly a democratic nation where human rights are respected.”

"We strongly urge you to pass this important legislation in the Senate.

"2) Speak out on the human rights abuses in Vietnam

“Your voices—in today’s hearing, through letters, speeches on the Senate floor, and in meetings with Hanoi officials—are important in demanding that the regime release all political prisoners and cease all forms of harassment against democracy activists and their families.

"3) ’Support democratic change

"As long as there is a one-party dictatorship, human rights abuses will persist. The solution to
human rights is a democratic society where all stake-holders have a voice in the future of their
country. While achieving democracy must be foremost an effort of the Vietnamese people, the
international community can help by enabling the activities of independent NGOs, promoting an
independent media and collaborating with grassroots organizations inside Vietnam.

"This is essential for empowering the Vietnamese people and building a civil society,'' he said, "the critical foundation upon which a long lasting democracy can be achieved. ’

Digg Delicious Facebook Fark Google Newsvine Reddit Yahoo

Comments

Why don't we just eliminate activists?
There are so many groups out there for special
interests its sickening.
If we must have activists how about one for the average American.


Why don't we just eliminate activists?
There are so many groups out there for special
interests its sickening.
If we must have activists how about one for the average American.

Posted by: Paul Jaeger | March 12, 2008 4:40 PM


Yes, Down with activists!

If only the governments of the day had arrested John and Samuel Adams, Patrick Henry, Thomas Jefferson, Frederick Douglass, Sojourner Truth, Susan B. Anthony, Martin Luther King, Cesar Chavez, and all those other evil evil activists, this would be so much better a country. No more pesky freedoms, nothing stopping the government from exerting complete control over our lives.

Down with Freedom! Down with Activism! Up with dictatorship!


Viet Nam is old news. Why Congress even bothered to hold hearings is beyond reason. We lost; the Viet Cong won - close the book! Is this another CIA attempt to start another war or covert action under the guise of human rights? If our current government cared about human rights or holding people without due process, then they need only look in their own backyards via Guantanemo. Moreover, Congress could do better things with tax payer money than go sticking their noise into the business of other nations, especially one that left a horrific blemish on our military and the morale of this nation. Viet Nam - a dead issue. Leave us out.


Good God; let's hope one of McBush's new wars isn't going back into VN!!!

Here's what we do; LEAVE VIETNAM ALONE.

Thank you.


"If we must have activists how about one for the average American.

Posted by: Paul Jaeger | March 12, 2008 4:40 PM"

That would be you, and the status-quo.


the Truth,

Sad, but true.

We have no moral standing what so ever in VN/Cambodia/Laos. The whole endeavor was the worst mistake of the 20th century regardless of whose 'ideals' may have been more righteous.

Absolute proof that 'the ends do not justify the means'.

I agree with Morris, leave em be. They don't want to see us around no mo!

Besides, they may soon be creditor nations, and we will need them to finance the 'paper' for other promised wars.

If we want to jerk some strong man junta's chain, let it be Saudi, Egypt, Pak, or any of the Central Asian 'Stans' where we have military bases and oil interest.
Oops, I guess I just hit a nerve with that one.

Sad but true.


It also occurs to me, the last thing we need is another teeny tiny but vocal minority calling the foreign policy tune for the US.
See Cuba and Israel lobby.


Paul Jaeger,
The reason there aren't any 'average American' activists is, they are all sitting on the couch, drinking pop and beer, eating snacks, getting fat, watching 'reality' TV.


Recenlly . VietNam Communist gorvenment has arrested many activists who have fought for demoncracy , freedom and human rights for 84 millions Vietnamese .

1- Doctors , lawyers , Professors , Students , Workers , Buhdish monks , Fathers ... All of them now in many pour condition Prisons around the country . Last month , One of those Dissidents has broken hand and the Jailers let him suffered days and nights without has the Dr's help to correcting the bones as it should be . (Truong Minh Duc ) as the man who hand now is getting worsed and may becomes handicaped in the near future .
Vietnam Gorventment treats their own people Brutally , inhumanitary , no Mercy at all .

People around the world is always saying :
" Freedom or death "
In our country ( VN ) or other countries which are under communist rulers as Cuba , North Korea , China . When you say the word ( freedom ) you are in the bad shapes . If you say ( human righs ) . You go to jail . If you say the gorventment are the group of bullshits then you certainlly (dead meat ) .

The living conditions in Vietnam nowaday is No freedom of speech , no freedom to Pratice Religions or the rigths of choosing where to live ...the facts that it gorvenment always try to hide to US and the people around the world is - The life in Vietnam under Communist Party is the same as living in a big prison and the guards are the polices and the law is on their hand . No freedom at all .


Nha,

I certainly take your side on the freedom issue. My point would be, we bombed Indochina back to stone age as a policy, therefore we have little moral standing there.

The US should in no way interfere militarily or covertly. (The CIA is so inept it can't figure the obvious, let alone Asian politics)

And the name 'Diem' really rings a bell. Where have we heard that one? Any relation? If so, I hope he remembers who killed his ancestor.

And finally, the USA has always had trouble figuring out who the good guys actually are, so it always defaulted to anybody that wasn't a communist, such as Diem, Thieu, Lon Nol in Cam.


C. Morris:

No one is asking the US to bomb VN or doing anything militarily. There are diplomatic ways to persuade dictatorship goverments like VN to change their ways. VN communist padres have a lot of personal businesses in the US and they certainly don't want to lose them. We should be able to convince them that a democratic goverment is even good for the them too.


Ryan,

That would be the only way, but we have no record of above board dealings in SE Asia.


HEY GUYS,

WE ARE A BUNCH OF CROOKS, BIG LIARS.

DO YOU KNOW ?


Post a comment

(Anonymous comments will not be posted. Comments aren't posted immediately. They're screened for relevance to the topic, obscenity, spam and over-the-top personal attacks. We can't always get them up as soon as we'd like so please be patient. Thanks for visiting The Swamp.)

Please enter the letter "e" in the field below:

Quizzes

palin or fey

Palin or Fey?

McCain

Know the presidents?

McCain

Your McCain IQ

Obama

Your Obama IQ

Latest polls

Electoral vote map

map

Test your scenarios

Galleries

Palin

Sarah Palin

campaign

Campaign trail

conventions

RNC | DNC

Unauthorized tour

Obama

Obama's Chicago

News, but funnier

Cartoon

Walt Handelsman

Cartoon

The Lowe- Down

Cartoon

Joe Fournier

Cartoon

Editorial cartoons

Candidate match


Test assumptions