The Swamp
-
Posted May 4, 2008 7:00 AM
The Swamp

by Don Frederick

Small-town folks just aren't getting much respect these days from some big-time politicians.

Indeed, the phenomenon has become bipartisan -- add California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger, a Republican, to the list that Democratic presidential candidate Barack Obama started when he famously opined that those living in lesser populated areas often "cling" to guns, God and other matters out of bitterness over their economic plight.

Obama made his comments at a private event in San Francisco; Schwarzenegger was less discreet, holding forth during an appearance Wednesday at a conference in Beverly Hills (a gathering hosted by billionaire Michael Milken, whose post-prison endeavors include running an economic think tank).

As detailed by the Sacramento Bee, Schwarzenegger was reflecting on how international travel broadens one's horizons. To drive his point home, he said: "I always encourage the legislators in Sacramento (to take foreign trips), because some of them come from those little towns. You know what I'm saying? They come from those little towns and they don't have that vision yet of an airport.

"Or of a highway that maybe has 10 lanes or of putting a highway on top of a highway. They look at you and they say, 'Well, we don't have that in my town. What are you talking about?' So they are kind of shocked when you say certain things."

The Bee story reported that his comments sparked laughter and applause from his cosmopolitan crowd.

It also provoked a rebuke from a lawmaker contacted by the L.A. Times, state Sen. Dean Florez of the small Central Valley community of Shafter. Asked Florez (tongue firmly planted in cheek, we presume): "Does the governor think that I just normally fly up on 'crop dusters' to Sacramento field by field?"

And as word spread of Schwarzenegger's remarks, they spurred an indignant e-mail sent to the media by Karen England, executive director of the Capitol Resource Institute (a Sacramento-based group that, according to its website, serves as "watchdog for family values.")

"Most Californians are from small towns, and those citizens are hard working Americans with traditional values," England wrote. "For the governor of California to ridicule legislators, and their constituents, is disgusting."

She added: "These unbelievable comments are further proof that Arnold Schwarzenegger is completely out of touch with our state and is an elitist."

Perhaps he'll want to consult Obama on damage control (his wife, Maria Shriver, can put the two together).

Don Frederick is a Washington editor for the Los Angeles Times and wrote this for Top of the Ticket, the L.A. Times' political blog.

Digg Delicious Facebook Fark Google Newsvine Reddit Yahoo

Comments

So, the thing that the Governator takes away from his international travels is 10-lane highways and double-decker roadways? Wow, how cosmopolitan.


I think the only reasonable solution is to change the rules and only give small town residents 1/2 a vote in the up comng elections.


I've lived in small towns and agree with that provincialism is the number one commodity in such places. This does not mean that people are out of touch with their lives and the things that are important to them any more than people who live in big cities are out of touch with their lives and having to deal with overcrowding, noisy neighbors, automobile gridlock, finding places to park and all the other great things that define life in modern America. The fact is there are problems attendant to both rural and urban areas that need addressing. I don't think that either Obama or Schwarzeneger are putting anybody down, but are suggesting that people look outside of their comfort zones and see what is out in the world to help improve upon their environments. Small towns have big problems with meeting the needs of juveniles and young people. It should come as no surprise that a lot of the blockbuster crimes that have taken place are in small towns. So they are not little Mayberry US of A's filled with Mrs Cleavers.


If an award exists for the most outrageously inaccurate statement, Karen England should be the runaway winner this year. Most Californians are NOT from small towns. More than 80 percent of them live in metropolitan areas with 1 million people or more. This has been the case for a quite some time now. I wonder where she gets her facts.


Post a comment

(Anonymous comments will not be posted. Comments aren't posted immediately. They're screened for relevance to the topic, obscenity, spam and over-the-top personal attacks. We can't always get them up as soon as we'd like so please be patient. Thanks for visiting The Swamp.)

Please enter the letter "m" in the field below: