War, service, remembrance and debate: The Swamp
 
The Swamp
-

If Americans are divided over the war, they honor the service of the warriors. Yet service itself could become a campaign issue in the months ahead.

Posted May 24, 2008 10:06 AM
The Swamp

by Mark Silva

In the sixth year of the war in Iraq - think about that phrase for a moment - President Bush is pausing this weekend to honor the heroes who have fallen for their country.

It's the Memorial Day weekend.

On Monday, the president will lay a wreath at the Tomb of the Unknowns at Arlington National Cemetery.

Today, the president speaks of the valor of those serving in Iraq and Afghanistan, and of the cause to which the commander-in-chief has committed these forces:

"Today, the men and women of our military are facing a new totalitarian threat to our freedom,'' Bush says in his weekly radio address. "Iraq, Afghanistan, and other fronts around the world, they continue the proud legacy of those who came before them. They bear their responsibilities with quiet dignity and honor. And some have made the ultimate sacrifice in defense of their country.''

Service itself is honored, despite an unresolved domestic dispute over the war.

And service itself already has surfaced as a potentiially divisive issue in the campaign to replace the president whose two terms may be remembered largely for the U.S.-led invasion of Iraq and a seemingly intractable U.S. commitment to the conflict there.

This week, the Senate approved a war-funding bill which, despite the president's objections, piled much more money on the table for a generous GI Bill for the higher education of those who have served since Sept. 11, 2001.

Sen. John McCain, the Republican Party's presumptive presidential nominee and a supporter of Bush's latest war strategy, sides with those insisting on keeping the war-funding bill clean of any additional spending. Sen. Barack Obama, the all-but-decided Democratic nominee who has opposed the war since its start, said on the Senate floor this week that he "can't understand why'' McCain "would line up behind'' Bush in opposing GI Bill funding.

"Perhaps, if Senator Obama would take the time and trouble to understand this issue he would learn to debate an honest disagreement respectfully,'' McCain said in a statement issued while campaigning in California. "But, as he always does, he prefers impugning the motives of his opponent, and exploiting a thoughtful difference of opinion to advance his own ambitions. If that is how he would behave as president, the country would regret his election."

And McCain, a Naval aviator who suffered torture at the hands of North Vietnamese captors during five and a half years as a prisoner-of-war, added this about Obama, who has not served in the military: "I will not accept from Senator Obama, who did not feel it was his responsibility to serve our country in uniform, any lectures on my regard for those who did."

McCain has been loath to play the "I wore the uniform, you didn't" card, our colleagues at the LA Times' Top of the Ticket blog have noted: "After all, he could have laid it on the table during his often bitter battle with Bush for the GOP's 2000 presidential nomination. And it was available again -- to be directed at both Bush and Vice President Dick Cheney -- during McCain's intense strategic disagreements with the administration over the Iraq war.''

Obama measured his own response to McCain's comments, dismissing them as "schoolyard taunts" that "do nothing to advance the debate about what matters to the American people."

So, Happy Memorial Day weekend, and see the radio address here:

Thiis is the text of the president's weekly radio address:

Good morning. This Memorial Day weekend, kids will be out of school, moms and dads will be firing up the grill, and families across our country will mark the unofficial beginning of summer. But as we do, we should all remember the true purpose of this holiday -- to honor the sacrifices that make our freedom possible.

On Monday, I will commemorate Memorial Day by visiting Arlington National Cemetery, where I will lay a wreath at the Tomb of the Unknowns. The tomb is the final resting place of three brave American soldiers who lost their lives in combat. The names of these veterans of World War I, World War II, and the Korean War are known only to God. But their valor is known to us all.

Throughout American history, this valor has preserved our way of life and our sacred freedoms. It was this valor that won our independence. It was this valor that removed the stain of slavery from our Nation. And it was this valor that defeated the great totalitarian threats of the last century.

Today, the men and women of our military are facing a new totalitarian threat to our freedom. In Iraq, Afghanistan, and other fronts around the world, they continue the proud legacy of those who came before them. They bear their responsibilities with quiet dignity and honor. And some have made the ultimate sacrifice in defense of their country.

One such hero was Sergeant First Class Benjamin Sebban of the Army's 82nd Airborne Division. As the senior medic in his squadron, Ben made sacrifice a way of life. When younger medics were learning how to insert IVs, he would offer his own arm for practice. And when the time came, Ben did not hesitate to offer his fellow soldiers far more.

On March 17, 2007, in Iraq's Diyala province, Ben saw a truck filled with explosives racing toward his team of paratroopers. He ran into the open to warn them, exposing himself to the blast. Ben received severe wounds, but this good medic never bothered to check his own injuries. Instead, he devoted his final moments on this earth to treating others. Earlier this week, in a ceremony at Fort Bragg, North Carolina, I had the honor of presenting Sergeant Sebban's mom with the Silver Star that he earned.

No words are adequate to console those who have lost a loved one serving our Nation. We can only offer our prayers and join in their grief. We grieve for the mother who hears the sound of her child's 21-gun salute. We grieve for the husband or wife who receives a folded flag. We grieve for a young son or daughter who only knows dad from a photograph.

One holiday is not enough to commemorate all of the sacrifices that have been made by America's men and women in uniform. No group has ever done more to defend liberty than the men and women of the United States Armed Forces. Their bravery has done more than simply win battles. It has done more than win wars. It has secured a way of life for our entire country. These heroes and their families should be in our thoughts and prayers on a daily basis, and they should receive our loving thanks at every possible opportunity.

This Memorial Day, I ask all Americans to honor the sacrifices of those who have served you and our country. One way to do so is by joining in a moment of remembrance that will be marked across our country at 3:00 p.m. local time. At that moment, Major League Baseball games will pause, the National Memorial Day parade will halt, Amtrak trains will blow their whistles, and buglers in military cemeteries will play Taps. You can participate by placing a flag at a veteran's grave, taking your family to the battlefields where freedom was defended, or saying a silent prayer for all the Americans who were delivered out of the agony of war to meet their Creator. Their bravery has preserved the country we love so dearly.

Thank you for listening.


Digg Delicious Facebook Fark Google Newsvine Reddit Yahoo

Comments

On this Memorial Day weekend, just what service, if any, has Obama ever performed for this country? The answer is zero. The thought of putting this neophyte in charge of our military, in charge of anything above the grade of checking out books in a library, is nothing short of frightening. Hard to imagine a man of no achievement or accomplishments running for the highest office in the land.


It is a shame that those who claim to support the troops turn their backs on them when the troops need them.

They hide behind flag pins with "made in China" stamped on the back.

McCain's remarks that he is the only one who understands veterans needs and that Obama does not understand the military is a slap in the face to Webb, John W. Warner, the 75 out of 97 Senators (Republican and Democrat alike) who voted for it and every solider fighting or who has fought in the current Afghanistan and Iraq wars. Webb and Warner are former Secretaries of the Navy for crying out loud. What makes McCain think he is the only one who is qualified to make a decision about the military? He sounds more and more like Bush everyday.

You want more of the same, vote McCain.

My vote is for Obama.


So many people keep following the pied piper regardless of his abilities, experiences,and connections. A Chicago politician should be a warning. Unfortunately a lot of people want to believe of promised better times. He was put up front by the old time congressional leaders because they couldn't rule any other way.


I would like to take this moment to thank our men and women in uniform, particularly, those in Iraq, who are in harm's way. Thank you for your service, which has been above and beyond and I pray that you return safely, ASAP!!
SUPPORT OUR TROOPS, BRING THEM HOME, ALIVE. NOW.


Hard to imagine a man of no achievement or accomplishments running for the highest office in the land.

Posted by: Gavin | May 24, 2008 10:20 AM


Gavin your disparaging comments are tedious. This weekend we should be thanking our currently deployed troops, and people like my father and my comrade in arms who gave their lives for this great country. I think we should all take a minute to really think about this so-called war on terror and the direction of this country the last few years. Our troops deserve a respectful, thought out debate on the war in Iraq. This weekend isn't the time to do it. This weekend is for them!!! God Bless America!!!


We should be thinking about the military. The troops who serve now and the ones who came before. Thank you for all you've done for our country. That includes John McCain.


Obama in 2008!


McCain - "a thoughtful difference of opinion"

I have yet to hear from any of the big media news organizations - what exactly are McCain's reasons for why he is against giving vets money to cover a basic, public college education?


He wants to keep them in the service longer.


I would like to thank the troops who have fought the President's war and apologize to them for John McCain's and the Republican Party's ingraditude for that service.


McCain continues to support the millionaires of this country who do not have children, grandchildren in the war, consequently no need for help in education. Course they don't need it anyway.
Any person who has risked their life for an unjustified war deserves everything this country can offer.
McCain and Bush continue to be oblivious to the needs, wants and rights of the voters of this country. They and their fellow republicans are totally responsible for the crisis our country is in. How anyone can to continue to support them is a mystery to me.


I would like to thank the troops who have fought the President's war and apologize to them for John McCain's and the Republican Party's ingraditude for that service."


"McCain continues to support the millionaires of this country who do not have children, grandchildren in the war...."


Maybe they are fighting for this country because they think it is the right thing to do.

The men and women in the military volunteered to serve, they come from all walks of life. They don't need your meaningless apologies.


They don't need you to tell them they are fighting the 'Presidents' war or they are too poor and stupid to do anything else.

Despicable comments from despicable people on Memorial day.


Post a comment

(Anonymous comments will not be posted. Comments aren't posted immediately. They're screened for relevance to the topic, obscenity, spam and over-the-top personal attacks. We can't always get them up as soon as we'd like so please be patient. Thanks for visiting The Swamp.)

Please enter the letter "o" in the field below: