Bush: U.S. military taking aid to Georgia: The Swamp
The Swamp

Military will deliver humanitarian aid to Georgia, the president says.

Posted August 13, 2008 11:30 AM

The Swamp

by Mark Silva and updated with Russian and Bush statements.

President Bush, declaring "solidarity'' with the people of Georgia, is dispatching Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice to Paris and then Tbilisi and sending a military and Naval armada of humanitarian aid and medical supplies to the besieged nation.

Bush, making a Rose Garden appearance with Rice and Secretary of Defense Robert Gates by his side, maintained that the actions of Russia do not conform with its statement that it is not threatening the democratically elected government of Georgia.

"Russia's ongoing actions raise serious questions about its intentions,'' Bush said. "Russia must keep its word and act to end this crisis.... We expect Russia to meet its commitment.''

The president, announcing "a series of steps to demonstrate our solidarity'' with Georgia, said a C-17 military transport already is on its way with humanitarian aid and Defense Secretary Gates will lead a humanitarian mission involving both U.S. aircraft and Naval forces in the delivery of food and medical supplies.

Endorsing the efforts of French President Nicolas Sarkozy, head of the European Union, to broker a peace agreement between Russia and Georgia, Bush said Rice first will travel to France to meet with Sarkozy and then travel to Tbilisi, the Georgian capital.

Rice will 'rally the free world,'' Bush said.

"Russia has stated that changing the government of Georgia is not its goal,'' Bush said. "The United States... and the world... expect Russia to honor that.'' However, he said, "unfortunately,'' Russia's continuing actions in Georgia - blocking ports and attacking ships - are "inconsistent with that statement.''

Within an hour after the president's statement, the Russian government issued a statement today, with President Dmitry Medvedev declaring today "a day of mourning for the humanitarian disaster in South Ossetia.''

Claiming that the Russian Air Force had "terminated all bombardments'' as of Aug. 12 and that there are no Russian tanks in Gori, the government said that medical units had started working in the "practically destroyed'' city of Tskhinvali.

Calling the Georgians "the aggressor'' in the conflict that started five days ago, the Russian government said its "peacekeepers'' had suffered many casulaties: 74 killed in action, 171 wounded in action and 19 missing in action. It also said that "no withdrawal of Georgian forces can be seen.''

Georgian President Mikhail Saakashvili was taking his own appeal directly to the American people. The Georgian leader made appearances on morning network and cable news shows. See his comments, President Bush's statement today and the Russian government's statement below:

"The situation is dramatic,'' Saakashvili said today on CBS News' The Early Show. "We are witnessing a new stage of full-blown Russian invasion and aggression against my country.... the situation developing on three different fronts.

"First, in the... region of South Ossetia, where Russian tanks are going through villages inhabited by Georgian population and throwing people out of the houses, putting people into concentration camps that they are setting up in those villages and separating men and women and doing worse kinds of atrocities, unheard of since Balkans or since the war in Chechnya.

"The other thing is Upper Abkhazia, in the region of Abkhazia, which is several hundred kilometers -- miles -- away removed from the South Ossetia where they're going through villages again inhabited by Georgians and throwing out every single Georgian man or woman and children,'' he said. "And the third one is that they have moved into the town of Gori and they rampage the town, looted the town. These are regular Russian troops. They go into houses, they destroy houses. There is all this documentary footage around that can prove it.''


This is the text of the president's statement in the Rose Garden today:

THE PRESIDENT: Good morning. I've just met with my national security team to discuss the crisis in Georgia. I've spoken with President Saakashvili of Georgia, and President Sarkozy of France this morning. The United States strongly supports France's efforts, as President of the European Union, to broker an agreement that will end this conflict.

The United States of America stands with the democratically elected government of Georgia. We insist that the sovereignty and territorial integrity of Georgia be respected.

Russia has stated that changing the government of Georgia is not its goal. The United States and the world expect Russia to honor that commitment. Russia has also stated that it has halted military operations and agreed to a provisional cease-fire. Unfortunately, we're receiving reports of Russian actions that are inconsistent with these statements. We're concerned about reports that Russian units have taken up positions on the east side of the city of Gori, which allows them to block the East-West Highway, divide the country, and threaten the capital of Tbilisi.

We're concerned about reports that Russian forces have entered and taken positions in the port city of Poti, that Russian armored vehicles are blocking access to that port, and that Russia is blowing up Georgian vessels. We're concerned about reports that Georgian citizens of all ethnic origins are not being protected. All forces, including Russian forces, have an obligation to protect innocent civilians from attack.

With these concerns in mind, I have directed a series of steps to demonstrate our solidarity with the Georgian people and bring about a peaceful resolution to this conflict. I'm sending Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice to France, where she will confer with President Sarkozy. She will then travel to Tbilisi, where she will personally convey America's unwavering support for Georgia's democratic government. On this trip she will continue our efforts to rally the free world in the defense of a free Georgia.

I've also directed Secretary of Defense Bob Gates to begin a humanitarian mission to the people of Georgia, headed by the United States military. This mission will be vigorous and ongoing. A U.S. C-17 aircraft with humanitarian supplies is on its way. And in the days ahead we will use U.S. aircraft, as well as naval forces, to deliver humanitarian and medical supplies.

We expect Russia to honor its commitment to let in all forms of humanitarian assistance. We expect Russia to ensure that all lines of communication and transport, including seaports, airports, roads, and airspace, remain open for the delivery of humanitarian assistance and for civilian transit. We expect Russia to meet its commitment to cease all military activities in Georgia. And we expect all Russian forces that entered Georgia in recent days to withdraw from that country.

As I have made clear, Russia's ongoing action raise serious questions about its intentions in Georgia and the region. In recent years, Russia has sought to integrate into the diplomatic, political, economic, and security structures of the 21st century. The United States has supported those efforts. Now Russia is putting its aspirations at risk by taking actions in Georgia that are inconsistent with the principles of those institutions. To begin to repair the damage to its relations with the United States, Europe, and other nations, and to begin restoring its place in the world, Russia must keep its word and act to end this crisis.''

This is the Russian government's statement:

President of the Russian Federation Dmitry Medvedev has declared August 13 a day of mourning for the humanitarian disaster in South Ossetia.

The President signed a decree 'On Declaring a Day of Mourning for the Humanitarian Disaster in South Ossetia:

Georgian forces, in violation of the peace agreements in place in the Georgian-Ossetian conflict zone and the UN Charter, and with the sanction of the Georgian leadership, illegally invaded and attempted to seize South Ossetian territory on August 8, 2008, using aviation, heavy artillery and guns and killing the local population. This act constitutes genocide against the South Ossetian people. The city of Tskhinvali and other towns have been practically destroyed, creating a humanitarian disaster in South Ossetia.

Furthermore, an armed attack was launched against a Russian Armed Forces contingent stationed in the region in accordance with international agreements for normalising the situation in the Georgian-Ossetian conflict zone, which constitutes an act of aggression under the terms of the UN General Assembly's resolution of December 14, 1974.

As a result of these actions numerous civilians in South Ossetia have been killed and members of the Russian Armed Forces peacekeeping contingent in the region have also lost their lives.

The President expressed his condolences to the families of the victims and declared August 13, 2008 a day of mourning in the Russian Federation.

Briefing by Deputy Head of the General Staff

Col-Gen Anatoly Nagovitsin

Wednesday 13 August 2008


Key statements:

· Russian casualties among peacekeepers: 74 KIA; 171 WIA; 19 MIA

· There are no Russian tanks in Gori

· By 12 August, Russian air force had terminated all bombardments

· Medical units started working in Tskhinvali

· In last 24 hours reconnaissance was being conducted to protect the facilities

· No withdrawal of Georgian forces can be seen

· The disarming operation in Abkhazia was conducted successfully

· The Russian Black Sea fleet is assisting the peacekeeping operation. One ship was attacked

· Georgian troops were armed with illegal weapons

Col-Gen Nagovitsin showed a map captured by Russian paratroopers 11 August. It depicts a detailed operations plan, which includes as targets not only Tskhinvali but Sukhumi as well. The plan includes a sea-based attack.

Q&A- Russian answers

1. Exchange of captured servicemen: a "list to list" exchange was proposed to Georgian side. For the moment there is no new data on civilians killed. Humanitarian operations are underway.

2. Abkhazia: the number of peacekeepers is sufficient, although snipers are still firing. The Georgian side violated the 1992 agreements, and a legal infrastructure is hard to restore. We are at a "wait and see" stage now. We're monitoring the situation.

3. No one is in charge of Gori now and Russian is appealing to the Georgian side on this issue. Georgian troops were disarmed with no resistance in the Kodori Gorge, and there is no threat to the peacekeepers.

4. The aggressor always has an advantage. Ukraine assisted with the arming of Georgian forces, including air defence systems. Only 585 peacekeepers were resisting against Georgian troops. The Russian air force had difficulties and many casualties at the beginning of the engagement, and carpet bombing was not successful.

5. You [the journalists] and I have done a lot to break through the fake words presented in the media. Saakashvili said he was in South Ossetia when Russian tanks were bombing there. Yet this is a lie, as he didn't leave Tbilisi and did not appear in Tskhinvali.

6. No comments given on a possible re-deployment of the peacekeeper force and on the Georgian decision to leave the CIS, as these are political questions.

7. It's difficult to categorise those who perished (ground troops or pilots). There will be additional info later.

8. The Russian reaction on Georgian operation was timely. We monitored Georgian military exercises. We also carried out ours. We secretly observed peacekeepers' status. We didn't expect Georgia to behave so inhumanely.

9. After the announced cease-fire there were sporadic shots, with some snipers continuing. We must respond to provocations. Russia will reply to firings.

10. It's difficult to say why Georgian forces abandoned Gori.

11. I'm familiar with the information about the journalists who perished in Gori but we lack clear-cut facts. As soon as have the information we will share it with you. Heavy weaponry was present in Kodori Gorge, but fortunately the bloodshed was prevented there.

12. 34 journalists in the region work in an organised manner. The editorial offices are responsible for the others. If you want to go, we organise the trips now. Regarding the RTR group, one journalist is in a hospital and is feeling better. We ask you not to make individual trips.

13. We used only regular weaponry such as high precision ammunition, guided missile "surgical strikes", etc... but nothing new.

Digg Delicious Facebook Fark Google Newsvine Reddit Yahoo

Comments

Meantime, here was Obama's "3 a.m. moment" and initial response to Russia's blatant aggression against a US ally. He could be describing a fight between two neighborhood boys. "I strongly condemn the outbreak of violence in Georgia, and urge an immediate end to armed conflict. Now is the time for Georgia and Russia to show restraint, and to avoid an escalation to full scale war."
Then Obama went back to his Hawaiian vacation. If Obama was in the White House, Russia would be occupying Ukraine by now. Obama is a weak, naive appeaser.


Whaaaaa?


What happened, Condi????

I thought you wuz the big expert on Russia.


So it's ok for Kosovo to to leave Serbia but not ok for Osettia and others to leave Georgia or Moldova? Total double standard. And we expect other countries to take us at our word? And the complete brazenous of the U.S. and media to lie about who started this attack when it was Georgia who started it. This idiot in Georgia isn't going to last much longer after this.


Russia is trying to go for the oil pipelines. Putin wants the USSR back. Time to put Russia back into its place. We need to draw the line on this or the U.S. creditability will go down the toilet!


The European Union. The great Union created to give America financial heartburn and competition on the world market for our goods, helping the American dollar devalue outside this country. I wonder if France and "her" EU nation partner's are willing to take on Russia. There's no mention of any form of "aid" coming from France or any EU nation's to Georgia? why is that? Maybe I just glossed over that information and didn't pick up on that.

So here we have America, once again expected to actually "assist" foreign countries with financial and military aid while the EU talks about themselves. Did Georgian President Mikhail Saakashvili take his appeal directly to the French? or the other EU Nations? He certainly came running to us, the American people. The Georgian leader made appearances on morning network and cable news shows.

What was Barry's response to any of this? When he did offer a response, he sounded more like a EU Frenchman than an American.


Putin and Medvedev are the new Saddam Hussein of the first Gulf War.


Derrick,
You would probably accuse Obama of acting as if he were POTUS if he used harsher rhetoric.
Besides, McCain has a dog in the race that Obama doesn't.
Surprise, surprise.
McCain's foreign policy adviser is a lobbyist for the Georgian government.


I'm sure a harshly worded statement by Obama would have made the Russian stop. That statement from McCain sure has them shaking in their boots.

Please folks, be real. There is nothing Obama could have done to stop this. There's nothing the US can do to stop this. Our military is stretched so thin as it is that the Russians know there is zero chance of us intervening. We simply don't have the ability right know to make a threat anything more than a hollow joke. That's where Bush has left us. Militarily impotent.


Please look your children in the eyes and ask yourselves, " is our expansion worth their lives?" because we have cornered Russia and we are about to force them to do the unthinkable. If Russia starts loosing this conflict they will launch a first strike because once our "missle interceptors" (which are probably something else) are in place they know we will be able to pick them appart peice by peice. Please stop and think this through. Do we really want to try to take Russia? And just keep in mind that Ukrain was the original capitol of Russia, and Georgia voluntarily joined Russia in the 1800s. WE ARE THE INVADERS this time- we are wrong. If we can't admit we are wrong on this one I hope you all have good basements and plenty potassium iodide.


Wow. The Bush team is so weak we have to send Condi Rice to FRANCE so Sarkozy can fill her in. If we had a foreign policy, we would have had high level diplomats in Georgia and Moscow last weekend. Oops, sorry, the Olympics are priority, I guess.


Putin wants to arrest Georgian President Mikhail Saakashvili and put him on "trial". Ah yes, the infamous Show Trial; turning jurisprudence into macabre theater in the best Stalinist tradition!


Hey Reality - you can thank the Clinton administration for making our military impotent. Clinton & Co. slashed the military budget to shreds. That is where the 'peace dividend' that Bill loved to talk about came from. When Clinton took office, we had 16 fully equiped and ready to go battalions. When he left office, we were down to 10 battalions but could only fully equip 1. There is a lot of things that can be blamed on Bush...but military impotence is not one of them. If anything, we should be thanking him for at least attempting to restore our military to pre-Clinton levels. At least as far as Congress would allow him.


Georgia's Saakashvili should soon receive the Goebbels Award for the best propagandist 2008. Seriously congrats for his PR campaign, a lot of his claims were debunked but just to be replaced by a new wave of delirious and to say the least ludicrous statements.


You're way off Sue. The reason we are impotent to help in Georgia is because Bush has us overextended in Iraq and Afghanistan. And the "peace dividend" reduction of military began under George H.W. Bush before Clinton. Will this "blame Clinton (or blame Carter) for everything" ever end??


Hey, ease up on Obama, he's doing for the country what he does best: Riding his surfboard, equivocating, stammering, and appeasing. And best of all, staying out of the way of the adults. Who said Obama's never done anything for
his(?) country?


@ Springfield

"There's no mention of any form of "aid" coming from France or any EU nation's to Georgia? why is that? Maybe I just glossed over that information and didn't pick up on that."

Exactly, you glossed over that information. To my knowledge France was the first to send some plane with humanitarian equipment, they also used it to evacuate foreign citizen from Tsibili.


How can you argue that this is Clinton's fault? Russia is simply exploiting the fact that our military is overstretched and we can not do anything to stop them. If we were not in Iraq, would Russia do this? NO WAY. Thanks Bush.


Susan-

Has Bill Clinton been President for tthe last 7 years?Has He?

Did Bill Clinton commit over 100,000 US troops to combat in Iraq for 5 years? Did he?


Sue,
The Cold War was over when Clinton took office. Furthermore it was Don Rumsfeld who wanted a "lighter, leaner military". Sorry to bring facts and perspective to the equation.


Reality and Sue,
Any disagreement that you have over the U.S's military size and/or capacity is rather irrelevant.
No matter if our standing army numbered one or one million, the U.S and her allies have wisely decided to not intervene militarily.
I think today's WSJ editorial has correctly zeroed in what it believes is the U.S's greatest leverage over Russia's hegemonic ambitions, shoring up the U.S dollar. Our weak currency has "greatly contributed" to soaring oil prices, and strengthening the dollar would "sober-up an oil drunk Kremlin".
This suggested course of action holds the greatest promise of curbing Russia's aggression.


What was Barry's response to any of this? When he did offer a response, he sounded more like a EU Frenchman than an American.

Posted by: Springfield | August 13, 2008 12:15 PM

Considering it's the French who are actually doing something to try and resolve this crisis and end the killing, I don't really think that's an insult. France has also been sending aid since Monday, We're just starting now.

http://uk.news.yahoo.com/rtrs/20080811/twl-uk-georgia-ossetia-france-plane-bd5ae06.html

http://cnews.canoe.ca/CNEWS/World/2008/08/11/6414241-ap.html

http://www.reuters.com/article/worldNews/idUSLA55688020080810


Don't bother Obama. There are a lot better things to do at Waikiki Beach than to worry about what's happening in Georgia. I'm sure Obama knows that Atlanta can take care of itself. It is the state of Georgia, isn't it? This may call for a speech in Berlin!!!


Thank you for that information reality. the French must have something going on I didn't know about.

Are we (US Government) doing the right thing by getting involved in this? Should we be sending military vessles over to the Caspian sea and holding off shore while telling Russia that we "United States of America stands with the democratically elected government of Georgia".

I'm not defending this stand and question how much involvement the US "we" should expose ourselves to. Can we absolutely count on the EU to back us up in times of trouble if Russia calls for a showdown at high noon? What would your advise be then?
If you can possibly leave BUSH out of your response, I would be more likely to read it.


Springfield-

This situation is a real mess, and there just isn't a whole heck of a lot the US can directly do about it. The Georgians were wrong to launch a military assault on the South Ossetian civilian areas. That act was both a human rights travesty, and incredibly reckless. The South Ossetians have been wrong in the past in their use of force to push for their independence from Georgia. The Russians are clearly wrong. There are no purely "good" guys to be found in this 3 sided mess.

That said, the EU has a lot more pull with the Russians at this point than we do, because of their greater economic ties. They also have a greater interest in solving this crisis because of their geographic proximity to the crisis. They have stepped up, especially France and Germany, to try and craft a diplomatic solution and to provide aid. I think this is a good time for the US to humbly accept a supporting role, and to support our NATO allies in their efforts. We don't always need to be calling all the shots. We're actually stronger if we have more of a partnership with our European allies, than strictly a leader/follower relationship.

I'd like to hear what you think a response "that sounds like america" rather than "EU France" would be. If you could leave Barry out of it, I'd appreciate it.


Actually, Batski, it was the Clinton administration that first offered aid to the Westernstyle gov't of Georgia and gave them assurances that we'd protect them from Russia.
The Clinton administration - in concert with our allies in Europe such as France and Germany - also brokered the deals to allow American companies to build oil and coal plants in Georgia's abundant fields. Russia didn't mind any of this UNTIL the new Georgian government, backed by the Clinton administration, cut Russia out of the transport deals for all the coal, oil and natural gas that Georgia supplies to Europe. That really got Pooty-Poot's dander up. That's why the first thing they bombed in Georgia was the Clinton-brokered pipeline that carries energy to Europe. President Bill Clinton personally pressed for the $4 billion Baku-Tiblisi-Ceyhan pipeline, which transports oil from the prodigious oil fields of Azerbaijan to the Turkish port of Ceyhan. So in short, yes this all started with the Clinton administration.

The Bush administration has supported attempts to find a way to get oil from Kazakhstan's enormous Kashagan field across the Caspian Sea to Azerbaijan as well, though right now it appears most of it will be shipped through Russia.
The problem is Putin doesn't want these countries on Russia's borders to obtain an independent supply of Western currency any more than he wants to lose control over the fuel-flowing West.
Russia's population is aging, and in another few decades the country will not be able to maintain a sufficient army to defend its borders, Ziehen said. Putin's strategy is to establish a protective crescent of subservient states, many of which just happen to contain important energy sources or transit points. Georgia will be just the first of many skirmishes with a fearful Russia.
By playing with the former Soviet republic of Georgia like a cat with a mouse, Vladimir Putin established who controls a very valuable piece of real estate and sent a message to the U.S. and anybody else who would find a secure route for Central Asian oil past Russian gatekeepers. Today, Putin has won and a US-backed democracy has lost.


Jeff, right now we don't have a sufficient Army to defend our borders. Perhaps we shouldn't be looking for a confrontation with Russia as a result.

http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2007/02/27/national/main2519581.shtml

http://www.stripes.com/article.asp?section=104&article=60825&archive=true


I thought Rice was an "expert" on Russia when she joined the Bush team. That was supposedly her selling point.


Post a comment

(Anonymous comments will not be posted. Comments aren't posted immediately. They're screened for relevance to the topic, obscenity, spam and over-the-top personal attacks. We can't always get them up as soon as we'd like so please be patient. Thanks for visiting The Swamp.)

Please enter the letter "b" in the field below:

Quizzes

palin or fey

Palin or Fey?

McCain

Know the presidents?

McCain

Your McCain IQ

Obama

Your Obama IQ

Latest polls

Electoral vote map

map

Test your scenarios

Galleries

Palin

Sarah Palin

campaign

Campaign trail

conventions

RNC | DNC

Unauthorized tour

Obama

Obama's Chicago

News, but funnier

Cartoon

Walt Handelsman

Cartoon

The Lowe- Down

Cartoon

Joe Fournier

Cartoon

Editorial cartoons

Candidate match


Test assumptions