by Mark Silva and updated at 11 pm
It's entirely possible that we may have seen a draw tonight, in the first of the presidential election debates of the season.
John McCain started tonight with a skaky voice on economic issues, in the midst of a congressional debate over an extraordinary debate over government intervention in an economic crisis. His voice grew stronger, however, as the debate moved to national security, the Republican nominee's calling card.
Democrat Barack Obama found a consistently strong voice in both the economic and national security debates, though it grew more contentious as they waded into foreign affairs. He also managed to get beyond his notoriously wordy approach to serious questions and directly confront most of the challenges tonight.
There were no body blows tonight, no fatal one-liners, no fatal flubs. There was the occasional mispronunciation of an unpronounceable name - Ahmadinejad. There was an occasional subliminal reference to the age of the older candidate, by the candidate himself. But there was no clear attempt by one or the other to exploit a fatal weakness.
There are two more debates left in this series.
One of them could prove more important than tonight's.
* * * *
The closing "leading question'' tonight: What do they think of another attack on the United States like the one of Sept. 11, 2001?
"I think it's much less than it was the day after 9/11,'' said John McCain, the Republican nominee for president. "We have a long way to go in our intelligence services... I can tell you, America is safer than it was on 9/11.''
"We are safer in some ways,'' said Democratic nominee Barack Obama. "But we still have a long way to go... The biggest threat we face now is not a missile coming across in our skies, it's in a suitcase...''
* * * *
John McCain tonight attempted to portray rival Barack Obama as "naïve'' in matters of foreign affairs.
Unlike President Bush, who looked into former Russian President and now Prime Minister Vladimir Putin's eyes and saw his "soul,'' McCain said tonight, he saw something else.
"I looked into Mr. Putin's eyes, and I saw three letters, a K, a G and a B,'' said McCain, mouthing an oft-used campaign line.
"I think Americans will judge... very seriously, who should be the next president of the United States,'' McCain said tonight. "I've been involved... in virtually every national security challenge we have faced in the last 20 years...
"I honestly believe that Sen. Obama doesn't have the knowledge and experience,'' said McCain, suggesting that Obama's "failure to acknowledge'' the "success'' of the surge of U.S. forces in Iraq is all-telling. "I have the ability and background and judgments to make this country secure.
"I don't think I need any on-the-job training,'' said McCain. "I am ready now.''
Obama responded that the ideals and values of the United States have "inspired the entire world... Part of what we need to do, what the next president needs to do.... Is to send a message to the world, that we are going to invest in education, we need to invest in the issues'' that are important to the world.
McCain closed tonight's debate with a reminder that he was a prisoner of war in Vietnam. "I know how to heal the wounds of war. I know how to deal with our adversaries.''
* * * *
On the question of the threat that terrorists in Afghanistan pose and the relative threat in Iraq, Barack Obama told John McCain tonight: "You don't muddle through the central front on terrorism... You don't muddle through going after bin Laden.''
"Sen. Obama doesn't seem to understand, there is a connection between the two,'' McCain replied.
* * * *
Republican John McCain, supporter of President Bush's war straegy in Iraq now, has said he would rather "lose an election than lose a war.''
Tonight, on the war in Iraq:
"Sen. McCain is absolutely right that the violence has been reduced'' in Iraq, because of the "brilliant performance'' of U.S. troops, Barack Obama told his rival . "John, you like to pretend that the war began in 2007... You were wrong,'' Obama said with the most forceful personal attack so far this evening, suggesting that any success attached to the :surge of U.S, forces overlooks a misguided war.
"I'm afraid Sen. Obama doesn't understand the difference between the tactic and the strategy,'' McCain said. "Sen. Obama refuses to acknowledge that we are winning in Iraq.''
"That's not true,'' Obama said. "That's not true.''
Obama asked, "The question is, was this wise?'
'
"Sen. McCain, in the rush to go into Iraq, said, you know what, we've been successful in Afghanistan,'' Obama said. "What I've said is, we should end this (Iraq) war responsibly. We should do it in phases... and, bolster our forces in Afghanistan. ''
* * * *
As they got deep into their debate over spending tonight, Barack Obama faced John McCain and said that all the runaway spending which he now criticizes is something that the Bush administration has supported - and McCain has supported Bush "90 percent'' of the time.
"It's well known that I have not been elected Miss Congeniality in the United States Senate,'' said McCain, deploying the same prepared and oft-used campaign trail line that he had used earlier in tonight's debate. He is, he said, the "maverick.''
* * * *
"It's hard to reach from that part of the aisle from so far to the left,'' John McCain said tonight, delivering a clearly prepared line tonight, which rival Barack Obama dismissed with a polite laugh
. The audience, silent.
The audience, silent.
"Tom,'' said Obama, quickly correcting himself , quickly yet awkwardly,. "John mentioned me being wildly liberal.... Mostly that's me just opposing George Bush's polices.''
These lines were not working very well in either direction, it seemed, one third of the way into the night's debate.
* * * *
"I've got a pen... this one's kind of old,'' said McCain, wagging a veto-like felt pen in the air and using a term about attacking runaway spending that doesn't really work in his favor. "I'm going to veto every spending bill that comes across my desk.''
McCain is proposing $300 billion of tax cuts for some of the biggest corporations in America, Obama said. "My attitude is, we've got to grow the economy.''
McCain suggested that Obama suspended his request for "earmark'' spending, money for special spending back home, only after he was in office for a while and looking for higher office.
"I didn't win Miss Congeniality in the United States Senate,'' said McCain. "I want to cut spending. I want to keep taxes low.''
Obama, whose voice was deep and firm in an encounter with McCain, his voice occasionally shaky, called McCain's proposals "a continuation of the last eight years... and we can't afford another four.''
* * * *
Before the debate this evening, Democrat Obama left his motorcade for a short walk into the performing arts center at the University of Mississippi where tonight's debate is playing out. He held hands with his wife Michelle.
Supporters in a small crowd nearby shouted, "We love you.''
"Thanks for having us,'' the nominee replied.
Obama was trailed by a large entourage that included senior strategist, David Axelrod., who will join others in the official campaign "spin room'' post-debate this evening.
* * * *
At one point early on tonight, the moderator asked Obama to direct his response direclty to McCain. "Are you afraid I can't hear him? asked McCain, with a joke that could get to the heart of a question a lot of voters are asking about the man who stands to become the oldest candidate ever elected to a first term as president.
* * * *
The first "leading question" from the narrator: ''Gentlemen, at this moment tonight, where do you stand on the financial recovery plan?''
"We are at a defining moment in our history. Our nation is involved in two foreign wars, and we are going through the worst financial crisis since the Depression,'' Obama said.
"We have to move swiftly, and we have to move wisely,'' the Democrat said gazing directly into the television camera.
"No. 1, we have to act wisely.. .. $700 billion is potentially a lot of money,'' said Obama, marching through his prepared talking points in as concise a manner as this candidate often wont to some rambling can do. He was direct, on point.
"That's why I'm running for president,'' he said.
John McCain, the Republican nominee, opened with "a sad note'' about "the lion of the Senate,'' Sen. Ted Kennedy, the Democrat from Massachusetts battling brain cancer and hospitalized today - Kennedy, whom McCain has joined in immigration reform and other bipartisan initiatives.
"I've been around a little while,'' said McCain, whose eyes were fixed on the moderator, not the home viewing audience.
"I went back to Washington,'' McCain said of the negotiations over the financial market bailout. "This isn't the beginning of end of this crisis. This is the end of the beginning... We've got a lot of work to do.''
But that left moderator Lehrer asking: Let's go back to my question here, folks, what do you think of the rescue plan?
Are they going to vote for the $700 billion bailout of the financial markets that the Bush admiistration is pushing through Congress?
"I'm optimistic about the ability of us to come up with a plan,'' Obama said.
"I hope so,'' said McCain, on the quetion of voting for the plan.
"We need more responsibility, but we need it not just when there's a crisis,'' Obama said.
* * * *
Welcome to your own personal spin room, the place where we'll attempt to sort out who scored what in tonight's debate, the first of the presidential debates of 2008.
We'll be live-blogging here when the debate starts.
Anyone who cares to warm up the board with some pre-debate spin is welcome, anyone who wants to weigh in -- in medias res -- is welcome too, and then of course, the clean-up crew will be working overtime.
* * * *
Tonight they debate. The judgments begin.
For Barack Obama and John McCain, engaged in a close, hard-fought and at times intensely personal contest for the White House, the first of the nationally televised presidential camapign debates tonight in Mississippi is a chance to plant in the minds of viewing voters one lasting image or thought that will help carry one to victory in 39 days. It is a chance to start closing a deal with voters that neither has nailed down yet.
It's not only their words, but also their carriage that may leave the most important lasting impression in the minds of those who watch tonight at 9 pm EDT - and those who will be subjected to the endless rotation of the hottest clips from this debate in a weekend of cable news recycling.
It is a chance not only to appear presidential, to present as a commander-in-chief in-waiting, but also to turn a few memorable phrases. Of course, a second debate will follow soon, and a third, before the election plays out on Nov. 4.
The runup to the debate - McCain's abruptly "suspended'' campaign in the midst of the congressional debate over a $700-billion financial-market bailout, with McCain at first calling for a delay in the debate and then finally agreeing today to carry on with it, campaign suspension finished - sets a shaky stage tonight. Obama will attempt to play the steady hand at the tiller, while McCain attempts to regain his grip on a contest in which polls show that Obama has gained something of a lead nationally.
It is the first debate, tonight, which will set the tone for all of their remaining engagements. He who stumbles on the stage at the University of Mississippi at Oxford tonight will spend the next two debates catching up. He who conquers will defend the castle again, on Oct. 7 at Belmont University in Nashville, and on Oct. 15 at Hofstra University in Hempstead, N.Y.
The moderator, anchor Jim Lehrer of the Public Broadcasting service, will want to steer the discussion tonight toward foreign policy, which is said to be the strong suit of the Republican nominee, a third-generation graduate of the U.S. Naval Academy and son and grandson of admirals, a retired Navy captain who spent five and half years as a prisoner of war in Hanoi, and, in his second career of public service, a member of Congress for the better part of 26 years who has traveled the world.
Yet the debaters are certain to seize whatever opportunity they find to steer the debate toward the economic crisis at hand in America, arguablly connected to the slated theme of the debate by the place that America's economy plays in a fast-changing world economy. And this is said to be the strong suit of the Democratic nominee, a Harvard-trained lawyer who has spent less than four years in the Senate but draws the support of more Americans, according to the polls, in his fitness for handling the economy.