N.Y. congressional test: Obama's win: The Swamp
The Swamp
Chicago Tribune
Posted April 24, 2009 5:00 PM
The Swamp

by Mark Silva, updated with RNC Chairman Michael Steele's statement, and with President Obama's statement at 6:45 pm EDT.

In the quiet knolls of the upper Hudson River Valley where a nationally contested election played out, the contest for the vacated seat of a congressman in a district that had voted Republican for some time was painted as a test of President Barack Obama's agenda.

Scott Murphy.jpg
If that was the test, Obama has won.

There's one winner, for sure: Democrat Scott Murphy, who today claimed victory in the 20th Congressional District of New York, whose incumbent left to assume, by appointment of the governor, the former Senate seat of Hillary Rodham Clinton, now secretary of state for Obama.

Jim Tedisco, the Republican contender for the seat of now-Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand, conceded defeat today in a contest that ended so close that it took weeks to recount it.

The Republican Party had flooded the market with negative campaign ads tying Murphy to the Obama agenda and the Wall Street meltdown -- and the Obama agenda has won. The Democrats will be popping corks in the old Tin 'n Lint in Saratoga tonight.

"I'd like to thank President Obama and Vice President Biden for supporting my campaign and for their inspiring leadership for our country,'' Murphy said today.

Obama issued this statement about a congressional candidate whom he had helped win: "With this hard-fought win, Scott has shown he is willing to fight the tough battles on behalf of the people in his district.... As a candidate, Scott courageously championed the economic plans we need to lift our nation and put it on a better path, and he will continue to do so in Congress.

"With his proven record of creating high paying jobs and standing up for Upstate New York, Scott will bring to the nation's capitol the change New Yorkers need,'' the president said, framing the race as an agenda-builder.

Republican National Committee Chairman Michael Steele, who campaigned for Tedisco in the district, said: "The Republican Party must be competitive in districts like NY-20 if we are going to regain our congressional majorities.

"While we were unsuccessful in this race, the combined efforts of our candidate, the national and state parties and NRCC show that the GOP is going to invest the resources necessary to regain our majority in the U.S. House of Representatives."

I can't wait to start working with the president to deliver the urgently needed recovery funds to Upstate New York,'' Murphy said. "I look forward to rolling up my sleeves in Washington to bring jobs, opportunity, and prosperity back to Upstate New York."

""Scott Murphy's long-awaited victory is proof positive that Americans, even in this heavily Republican district, support the president and want him to succeed, and the result is a repudiation of the failed policies of the past touted by Republicans," said Tim Kaine, chairman of the Democratic National Committee.

"Republicans decided to make this race a referendum on President Obama's leadership of the economy and his jobs and economic recovery plan - and given the result we are thankful that they did,'' he said. " Scott Murphy embraced President Obama's approach to the economy and his message of change while his opponent embraced the politics of division and the failed economic policies that got our country into the mess we find ourselves in today.

Murphy, a venture capitalist in the small town of Glens Falls - where the local newspaper won the Pulitzer Prize this week for its editorials about the closed doors of local government - has defeated Tedisco, minority leader of the New York State Assembly, by only a handful of votes.

Although the seat was held by a Democrat, Gillibrand had some of what the local voters in a GOP stronghold were looking for - including her alliance with the National Rifle Association.

Obama formally endorsed Murphy in an email to supporters in and around the New York congressional district, encouraging people to volunteer for the Democrat's campaign.

Republicans account for 42 percent of the registered voters in the district, Democrats 26 percent, the DNC notes. Gillibrand was the first Democrat elected in three decades.

The Republican National Committee put $200,000 into Tedisco's campaign. The RNC chairman, Steele, campaigned for the GOP's candidate in the district twice. The GOP ran a lot of ads pounding Murphy, and by connection, Obama.
.
While the parties argue over the meaning of the contest, New York has a new congressman.

Digg Delicious Facebook Fark Google Newsvine Reddit Yahoo

Comments

Please...would the marginal please tell me again how Obamas numbers are dropping and of the big rise to the republican party.


The dems kept thier seat, so that is their victory.

However, when the seat was contested in Nov 2008, Gillibrand won by 24 points, 62 -38. Now it was basically a toss-up. In other words, the dems lost 24 points on this.

Momentum is turning back to common sense.


Net gain for Democrats = Zero!!!!

The seat was already held by a Democrat....can you people on the left ever tell the whole truth??? Republicans were a whisker away from picking up a seat!! How in the heck do you turn this into some kind of ringing endorsement for Obama???


The Republican party has become a nation wide laughingstock. This was a Republican district. Kirsten Gillibrand was the first Dem to win it in years and she only won it because her Republican opponent at the time (John Sweeny) got busted for getting wasted with a bunch of underaged frat boys at a frat party.
http://blogs.timesunion.com/capitol/archives/983



Net gain for Democrats = Zero!!!!

The seat was already held by a Democrat....can you people on the left ever tell the whole truth??? Republicans were a whisker away from picking up a seat!! How in the heck do you turn this into some kind of ringing endorsement for Obama???
Posted by: Joe | April 24, 2009 5:10 PM
.


The Republican in this case (Jimmy Disco) was up by 20% in the polls, in a Republican leaning district, less than a month before the election....and you call that a Repug "victory"?


Ha ha ha! It's amazing what passes for "success" with the Repug minions these days.



This was a special election and the turnout was stunted. As an incumbent assemblyman with a 26 year network in the Republican Party, Tedisco should have won by a large margin. I suspect if this election was run in November, Murphy's margin would actually have been larger.

The GOP has tarnished their product to the point where it is difficult to win an election anywhere except the 9 states that have that remain Republican strongholds


Republicans were a whisker away from picking up a seat!!

Posted by: Joe | April 24, 2009 5:10 PM
-----------------------------------------------
"Republicans account for 42 percent of the registered voters in the district, Democrats 26 percent"
-----------------------------------------------
Anyone notice a flaw in Joe's logic?


How about giving some props to Senator Gillibrand, who cut ads and campaigned for Murphy, and her personal popularity here almost surely put him over the top?

When she was picked the critics pounced insisting this seat would be lost to the GOP. With her hard work and popularity here, she helped her party save this seat. I'd say it's no small feat.


Anyone notice a flaw in Joe's logic?

Posted by: Kenneth Janowski | April 24, 2009 6:23 PM


Everyone except joe!


God forbid the Republicans from picking up any seats, anywhere. Remember, the Republicans never do anything FOR this country, they only do things TO this country!! whiteagle38


How is this anything to do with "Obama's victory"?

I thought Caroline Kennedy was the one Obama wanted in the Senate and the Clintons were able to scuttle her and put the one term rep. in in her place.
And this redheaded guy is just a stand in for her.
Caroline Kennedy got shaftedby the Clinton machine because she supported Obama (bless her!).

So how is this a victory for Obama?

If anything, it's a victory for the Clinton machine, by extension.


Just hope he is not an Obama "Rubber Stamp".

Wonderful if we could see more Democrats with a mind of their own .


"Republicans account for 42 percent of the registered voters in the district, Democrats 26 percent"

Thank you for that valuable information....sounds to me like we need to investigate this situation!! We all know how Democrats magically come up with those tiny margins of victory!! How many votes were found in the trunk of some union members car????


Please...would the marginal please tell me again how Obamas numbers are dropping and of the big rise to the republican party.
Posted by: bill r. | April 24, 2009 5:01 PM

For starters Obma won't produce his birth certificate
.
Hint, go to the internet for you news, the liberal TV and newspapers, especially The Chicago Tribune stink.


Post a comment

(Anonymous comments will not be posted. Comments aren't posted immediately. They're screened for relevance to the topic, obscenity, spam and over-the-top personal attacks. We can't always get them up as soon as we'd like so please be patient. Thanks for visiting The Swamp.)

Please enter the letter "e" in the field below:

Barack Obama
Want to see more photos? Click here

Play "Budget Hero"

Play Budget Hero

Latest polls

News, but funnier

Cartoon

Walt Handelsman

Cartoon

The Lowe- Down

Cartoon

Joe Fournier

Cartoon

Editorial cartoons

Quizzes

Rahm Emanuel

Know the real Rahm?

McCain

Presidential trivia