Bill Clinton, North Korea: Engaging: The Swamp
The Swamp
Chicago Tribune

The highest-profile U.S. official to visit North Korea in nearly a decade.

Posted August 4, 2009 7:25 AM
The Swamp

by John M. Glionna and Paul Richter and updated from Washington

SEOUL -- Former President Bill Clinton arrived in North Korea today in a dramatic bid to negotiate the release of two American TV journalists sentenced to 12 years in prison for illegally entering the secretive nation earlier this year.

Clinton, the husband of Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton, is the highest-profile U.S. official to visit North Korea in nearly a decade. His surprise visit signals the Obama administration's readiness to engage the communist dictatorship, even as Washington presses other nations to curb ties with the country, which recently resumed its nuclear program and tested ballistic missiles in defiance of United Nations resolutions.

Laura Ling and Euna Lee of San Francisco-based Current TV were taken into custody in March near the border with China while reporting on refugees fleeing North Korea. They were sentenced to hard labor for illegal entry and "hostile acts."

Lisa Ling, the sister of reporter Laura Ling, said Monday that the family could not comment on the report.

"Everything is just so delicate," she said. "We're going to wait it out a while longer. We're on pins and needles."

White House and State Department officials declined to comment on the mission, as did a spokeswoman for former Vice President Al Gore, a co-founder of Current TV. But another U.S. official, who declined to be identified, confirmed the mission. He said the Clintons were approached by the journalists' families when it became clear the North Koreans would permit a visit.

U.S. officials and North Korea watchers have predicted for some time that Pyongyang could be open to a visit from a high-ranking dignitary to discuss the women's imprisonment.

In Washington, a person familiar with the mission said that negotiations leading to Clinton's trip had "lasted for months."

Although North Korea's nuclear negotiator, Kim Kye Gwan, was among those who received Clinton at the airport in North Korea, the former president's goals were strictly humanitarian, this person said.

Among the officials deeply involved in the negotiations was Sen. John F. Kerry, (D-Mass.), chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee.

As another measure of the separation between the ongoing dispute over nuclear development in North Korea and Clinton's personal mission in Pyonyang, White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs issued a brief statement this morning:

"While this solely private mission to secure the release of two Americans is on the ground, we will have no comment,'' Gibbs said. "We do not want to jeopardize the success of former President Clinton's mission."

See the full story on Clinton's mission in North Korea in the Los Angeles Times and other Tribune newspapers and here in the Swamp:

With its love of pomp and circumstance, North Korea in the past has used celebrity visits for propaganda, trying to show that the outside world validates its system of government.

Scott Snyder of the nonprofit Asia Foundation said Clinton's standing as a world statesman carried weight with Pyongyang.

"The North Koreans have a lot of nostalgia for the end of the Clinton administration," he said.

"The question is going to be how could he go to Pyongyang without some assurance that they would be released," Snyder said.

"For someone at his level to go without a prior assurance of some kind would be to risk a huge loss of face."

The mission is especially delicate because U.S.-North Korean relations have fallen to a low point in recent months as the North has conducted a nuclear test, test-fired a series of missiles and broken off long-running disarmament talks.

U.S. officials have been debating whether to send an envoy. The mission poses the risk that the North will try to link the release to concessions on the nuclear issue, an effort the U.S. will want to resist, officials say.

Clinton's mission represents his first role for the Obama administration and another chapter in the two Clintons' long-intertwined public lives. Although Bill Clinton has not yet traveled with his wife in her official capacity as top U.S. diplomat, aides have not ruled out that the former president, who is involved in a number of international causes, would take part in some activity related to American diplomacy.

The visit comes at a time when the 67-year-old leader Kim Jong Il is reported to be gravely ill, having had a stroke last summer and, according to South Korean media reports, possibly suffering from pancreatic cancer.

Ralph Cossa, president of the Pacific Forum CSIS, a Honolulu-based think tank, said Clinton's visit will give the United States a rare opportunity to assess not only Kim's health, but who is actually making the decisions in North Korea.

"For me, this is a stroke of genius on the part of the Obama administration," said Cossa. "Kim Jong Il will have to meet with a former U.S. president. Given his ego and desire for attention, this is a photo opportunity he doesn't want to miss. If he doesn't meet with Clinton, we'll know he is on life support."

Neither the White House nor the State Department has said whether a meeting with the North Korean leader is planned.

An irony in the choice of Clinton is that Hillary Clinton and North Korean officials have recently engaged in a round of unusual name calling. She compared the regime to schoolchildren clamoring for attention, while the North Koreans described her as a "funny lady" and a pensioner.

But Hillary Clinton has been deeply involved in the case of the two journalists and has been trying to separate it from the larger U.S.-North Korean security dispute. At a recent town hall meeting at the State Department, Clinton sought to make progress by conveying the women's regret for what they had done and asking for amnesty.

"The two journalists and their families have expressed great remorse for this incident, and I think everyone is very sorry that it happened," she said during a question-and- answer session with State Department employees.

"What we hope for now is that these two young women would be granted amnesty through the North Korean system and be allowed to return home to their families as soon as possible."

Yet even as she has been pushing for the women's release, Clinton and the administration have been taking a very tough line on North Korea's behavior. Officials have insisted that they are not going to offer the North more incentives to return to the group disarmament talks.

Instead, they say North Korea must follow through on commitments to dismantle existing nuclear facilities and take steps toward eventual disarmament.

U.S. officials have been leading an effort to crack down on the North through tightened scrutiny of its ships and planes for arms that have been banned under a U.N. Security Council resolution. It is also trying to organize an international effort to cut the North off from the financing it has used to support its weapons trade.

Pyongyang's state media organ, the Korean Central News Agency, announced in a terse release that Bill Clinton had arrived in Pyongyang, the capital.

He and an undisclosed entourage "were greeted by Yang Hyong Sop, vice president of the Presidium of the Supreme People's Assembly, and Kim Kye Gwan, vice minister of foreign affairs," the release said.

A little girl presented a bouquet to Clinton, it added.

Jang Cheol-hyeon, a researcher at the Institute for National Security Strategy and a former official at North Korea's Unification Front Department, said Clinton's visit was the best chance the U.S. has to win the reporters' release.

"He can surely bring the two journalists back home," he said.

Lee Woo-young, a professor at the University of North Korean studies in Seoul, said Clinton's sudden visit suggested some behind-the-scenes negotiations had been taking place.

"It seems that this visit met some part of what North Korea has wanted," he said. "They wanted U.S. officials on the high-ranking level to come. This will have a positive effect in improving U.S.-North Korea relations."

Beyond the immediate issue of the journalists, Clinton's visit is an enormous publicity coup for Pyongyang, which has been seeking U.S. recognition for decades.

Clinton is the most important visitor since his secretary of State, Madeleine Albright, met with North Korean leader Kim Jong Il in 2000. It was thought at the time the meeting might pave the way for regular diplomatic relations and possibly a visit by Clinton, as a sitting president, but relations fell into a deep chill after George W. Bush entered the White House.

Former President Carter met with North Korea's founder, Kim Il Sung, shortly before his death in 1994 and struck a handshake deal on nuclear dismantlement.

New Mexico Gov. Bill Richardson, at the time a congressman, was used as a high-profile delegate in 1996 to secure the release of a U.S. citizen who swam across the Yalu River into North Korea.

But most high-ranking visitors to Pyongyang in recent years have been Chinese officials, though those visits have recently been curtailed because of U.N. sanctions imposed after North Korea's May 25 nuclear test.

Barbara Demick of The Los AngelesTimes' Beijing Bureau and Ju-min Park of The Times' Seoul Bureau contributed to this report.

Digg Delicious Facebook Fark Google Newsvine Reddit Yahoo

Comments

Wow!!! What a minute...you mean to tell me there is a president who is going to use diplomacy first?


Yeah, it worked so well with Nirth Korea when Jimmy Carter went there in the mid-90s. Sure he freed the journalist that was being help. But got Clinton to sign an agreement with Kim Jong, we will give you food (Kim still starved to death a million people), money, oil, and wait a nuclear reactor. All Kim Jong had to do was agree to suspend its nuclear program. Hmm, that worked so well.

Definition of Insanity, doing the samething over and over, an expecting different results.

Joe needs to google "Useful Idiots"


We need to continue the compoletly success full "Axis of Evil" Stategy of confrontation. Look at how that has led, to a free, open, democratic, non-nuclear North Korea. Yep that Bush strategy just worked worlds better.


I am not sure about this whole operation. Something to me smells fishy. It happened too quickly and smoothly, and not to mention it was Clinton male, not Hillary, whose job it was in the first place to handle this situation.


President Clinton was always great at Diplomacy.I have great faith that if anyone can help this situation with North Korea, it would be President Clinton.
runescape money


Bill Clinton Takes Private Jet Abroad To Pick Up Two Women...
In ordinary times this would be just another ordinary Headline for a typical 90’s news story. Nothing to see here people. Go home, nothing to see here! But these are not ordinary times and North Korea isn’t an ordinary threat. It’s been reported that this was a “surprise” trip. We all know this is BS. I can’t see Kim Joog Il coming out of the bathroom one morning and saying “Bill, is that you”? “I’m so surprised”!”Ah, if I’d known you were coming I’d have baked a cake”. One doesn’t travel to N. Korea in surprise fashion lest ye be shot down.


Good on Bill Clinton for helping free those people.


Post a comment

(Anonymous comments will not be posted. Comments aren't posted immediately. They're screened for relevance to the topic, obscenity, spam and over-the-top personal attacks. We can't always get them up as soon as we'd like so please be patient. Thanks for visiting The Swamp.)

Please enter the letter "c" in the field below:

Barack Obama
Want to see more photos? Click here

Play "Budget Hero"

Play Budget Hero

Latest polls

News, but funnier

Cartoon

Walt Handelsman

Cartoon

The Lowe- Down

Cartoon

Joe Fournier

Cartoon

Editorial cartoons

Quizzes

Rahm Emanuel

Know the real Rahm?

McCain

Presidential trivia