The Swamp
-

Economy Archives

Text size:  A A A A A

Economic doomsayers may be misleading

Posted May 6, 2008 7:00 AM
The Swamp

by William Neikirk

Amid the general gloom of today's economic news, it is refreshing to see contrarians raise their voices. They are hard to find these days, but they are out there, lurking, spreading a little joy.

Take Brian Wesbury and Robert Stein, economists at First Trust Advisors in Lisle, Ill. The recession that many economic analysts say has already started will never come to pass, they said in a report Monday.

Their take: Interest rates and tax rates are low. Productivity is growing strongly. "When these three things have been true, the U.S. has never fallen into recession. When these things are true, a financial market collapse is highly unlikely."

As for payroll job losses reported by the Labor Department for April, Wesbury and Stein noted that a separate jobs survey showed the unemployment rate declining. This separate survey, designed to measure the employment situation more broadly, has been stronger in recent months, they note. (Many economists, however, believe the payroll report is a more accurate measure of joblessness).

"The conventional wisdom is not always wrong," they said. "But because it depends so much on emotion, it can often mislead. Rather than dwelling on the bad news coming from the financial and housing sectors, we believe it is important to look at the underlying drivers of the economy. And those look very solid."

Also on Monday, an economist named Joel Naroff of Holland, Pa., took note of the April report of a non-manufacturing index cobbled together by supply managers. It showed that the non-manufacturing sector rose in April after having declined for three straight months.

"The U.S. economy is not the Temple of Doom as some economists have argued," Naroff reported. "Orders continued to expand even if only slowly." There were signs that firms added workers after having cut them in March, he said.

Overall business activity is still sluggish, conceded Naroff, but added: "The economy has not collapsed. OK, it is not great, but a major recession does not appear to be in the cards. Indeed, it is not clear that we will have more than one negative quarter (negative in economic growth)."

Continue reading "Economic doomsayers may be misleading" »

Digg Delicious Facebook Fark Google Newsvine Reddit Yahoo